The Impact of the Coronavirus on New York Federal and State Cases and Inmates
As of June 28, 2020, the outbreak of the novel coronavirus, COVID-19, has sickened over 10 million people and taken the lives of almost 500,000 – with these numbers rising dramatically every day and a resurgence in many places underway in the United States. New York alone accounts for over 392,000 cases. It has changed the way we live, how we interact with others, and how businesses operate. It also has caused a myriad of temporary changes in both the federal and New York State criminal justice systems. We have continued to monitor these developments of the pandemic as they affect new arrests, pending cases, and inmates who may be eligible for early release. If you have any questions concerning how the coronavirus has affected a loved one’s arrest or term of incarceration, do not hesitate to contact us for a free consultation.
How has COVID-19 Impacted New Arrests?
Arrests by New York State and City Law Enforcement Agencies
Unless an individual is issued a Desk Appearance Ticket (DAT), anyone who is the subject of a new arrest must be arraigned by a judge before he or she may be released. While bail is not required for most non-violent criminal offenses pursuant to the new bail reform laws, a court appearance is still required and the defendant will be held in a detention center or booking facility for a lengthy period of time before that may occur. Unlike most of New York, defendants in New York City are still not being produced to appear physically in court because of the virus. Instead, the arraignments occur virtually by video. As it takes longer to coordinate virtual arraignments, inmates are waiting longer in detention facilities before seeing a judge – routinely up to 36 hours. Because of the risks inherent in being held in a detention center or booking facility while bail is determined, we urge anyone who has been arrested or is the target of an investigation to immediately secure an attorney to negotiate a DAT – which is discretionary under certain circumstances – so that they may be released from the precinct and held for the minimum amount of time.
Federal Arrests in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York
New arrests, either via criminal complaint or indictment, are still being processed by federal magistrate judges. In the Southern District of New York, the court houses located at 500 Pearl Street in Manhattan and 300 Quarropas Street in White Plains remain open, but arraignments are only occurring at 500 Pearl Street. The courthouse located at 40 Foley Square in Manhattan is closed. While defendants are being produced to 500 Pearl Street for arraignments and bail arguments on new arrests, all other participants, including judges and lawyers, appear virtually and are not in the courtrooms during the proceedings. The same is true for the Eastern District of New York – new arrests are still being processed, however, arraignments and detention hearings are occurring virtually. These procedures have made lengthy confidential communications between defendants and counsel difficult – and as such, it is imperative that one facing a potential arrest retain an attorney at the earliest possible moment to ensure a sufficient opportunity for the preparation of a bail application.
Pending Cases in New York and Coronavirus’ Impact
Most New York City courthouses (New York, Kings, Queens, Bronx and Richmond Counties) remain open at this time, however, their operations are limited. For criminal cases, this includes emergency applications and requests for orders of protection and the review of bail. Recently, New York City courts entered phase two of their return to normal operations, which includes the return of certain family court cases to in-person appearances. All other New York State courthouses have entered phase three, which permits in-person appearances for select criminal plea and sentencing proceedings for defendants on bail, preliminary hearings for defendants being held in jail on felony complaints, and arraignments of defendants issued desk appearance tickets. While you should check with your attorney, most previously scheduled court appearances and all upcoming jury trials are being adjourned. Some judges are holding virtual status conferences with attorneys in hopes of resolving cases or keeping those with voluminous discovery or complex issues moving forward.
Time limits for the commencement of nearly all actions and filings have been extended to July 6, 2020 by Gov. Cuomo, however, this no longer applies to CPL § 180.80 as it did in March, April and May of this year. This means that if prosecutors cannot indict a non-bailed felony defendant within 120 hours of arrest (or 144 hours in the case of an intervening weekend or holiday) a preliminary hearing will be ordered by the court or the defendant must be released. At this preliminary hearing, the People will have the burden of establishing reasonable cause to believe that the defendant committed a felony. This exists when evidence or information which appears reliable discloses facts or circumstances which are collectively of such weight and persuasiveness as to convince a person of ordinary intelligence, judgment, and experience that it is reasonably likely that the offense was committed and that the defendant committed it. New York CPL § 70.10(2). While this places a low burden on prosecutors, they are required to establish reasonable cause through non-hearsay evidence. This means it is likely that the complainant or other witnesses will testify – and as such, will be subject to cross-examination by defense counsel long before trial. Notably, in New York City, these preliminary hearings are conduct virtually, whereas elsewhere they may be conducted in person.
Federal Cases in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York
Officially, both the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York remain open for business, however, new jury trials have been curtailed – in the EDNY until September 2020 – and most other appearances are occurring by telephone or video conference. In the Eastern District of New York, the chief judge has specifically authorized the use of video conferencing for detention hearings, initial appearances, preliminary hearings, waivers of indictment, arraignments, revocations of supervised release, and misdemeanor guilty pleas. Additionally, judges in the Eastern District of New York are permitted to conduct felony guilty pleas and sentencings virtually if they cannot be put off without serious harm to the interests of justice. In the Southern District of New York, 500 Pearl Street has remained open only to hear urgent criminal matters (arraignments / bail applications and reviews) and judges may conduct guilty pleas and sentencings in person by special arrangement. All other operations are either conducted virtually or put off. Despite court appearances being put off, discovery is still being reviewed by lawyers, motions are being filed, and dispositions are being negotiated as they would normally. While the districts employ a four phase opening plan, both remain in phase one with the return of select courthouse staff and no immediate plans to return to business as usual.
Early Release from Incarceration
There are presently applications pending throughout the criminal justice system for the release of inmates who may be especially at risk of death or serious complication due to the spread of COVID-19, indeed, lawyers at the Law Offices of Jeffrey Lichtman have already won the early release of three individuals serving federal sentences. How these applications are handled depends on the type of facility housing the inmate and whether an attorney is involved.
Inmates at New York City and State Facilities
As of June 28, 2020, 322 inmates presently housed at the Rikers Island jail complex have tested positive for the virus, over four times the rate of infection for New York City’s population and sixteen times the rate of infection for the United States. Three inmates have died from it and over 1,400 staff with the Department of Corrections have tested positive for the virus. In state facilities, 517 inmates have tested positive for the virus, 16 have died, and hundreds of inmates have already been released. Gov. Cuomo has committed to releasing more inmates in state custody, but the Department of Corrections is acting slowly. Unless a defense attorney is involved in the process and lobbying for the release of an inmate, the decisions as to whom should be released are being made by corrections officers and politicians.
If you have a loved one who is housed at a New York State or City facility and you are concerned that they might be at high risk of death or complication due to age or an underlying health complication, contact the Law Offices of Jeffrey Lichtman immediately. There are multiple avenues that may be pursued for release from a state or local detention facility when attorneys are involved – including petitioning prison officials for compassionate release and motions to judges for the modification of a sentence – and each should be explored immediately. Indeed, these applications are already being granted.
Federally Housed Inmates
COVID-19 has been found at both the Metropolitan Detention Center (MDC) and Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC), as well as many other federal detention centers, where visitation for both family members and lawyers has been curtailed for months, and lawmakers and BOP officials are slowly taking action to release the most vulnerable inmates. A recent report by the former chief medical examiner of New York City’s jails found conditions at both the MDC and MCC to be shockingly bad, with staff failing to take even basic precautions to keep inmates safe. Instead of waiting for these officials to take action on behalf of a family member or loved one, an attorney should be retained to start taking proactive steps on his or her behalf immediately. Even after a court issues an inmate’s compassionate release from incarceration, there are several administrative actions that must occur – and it can take days to facilitate even with an attorney involved. Presently, one inmate and four staff members are listed as infected with the virus at the MCC, and one inmate is listed as infected at the MDC, however, the numbers are likely much higher as officials have been unable to sufficiently test inmates.
First, an application with the prison should be filed seeking release of the inmate and establishing why he or she is at risk. To ensure that this application has the best chance of succeeding, an attorney should draft the papers. It may be that medical or other records must be sourced in order to file the application – and they may take some time to retrieve. An attorney is also needed to ensure that this application is ruled on by the warden on a timely basis. If the warden fails to take any action on the application, 30 days must pass from its filing before a motion to the court for relief may be made. While some federal judges have excused this requirement, others have strictly required its compliance before moving to the next step.
Second, if the warden has denied the inmate’s application for compassionate release or the 30- day period for his response has expired, an attorney may file with the sentencing judge a motion to modify an inmate’s previously imposed term of imprisonment pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A). This should be written in advance of the warden’s ruling so that it may be filed with the court without any additional delay. Successful applications have already been filed with courts, and judges in certain instances have converted the remaining portions of inmates’ sentences to home confinement.
Third, for inmates who have not yet been sentenced, an attorney should be retained to file a renewed bail application in light of the pandemic. This may be possible even if the defendant was previously denied bail, has already pleaded guilty, and is awaiting sentencing. To be sure, these applications are already being made and defendants thought previously to be unbailable are being released.
To determine if your family member or loved one qualifies for compassionate release or a renewed application for bail, please contact the Law Offices of Jeffrey Lichtman immediately for a free consultation.